Closed-Cell vs Open-Cell Insulation: What Moisture Actually Does to a Chilled Water Line
Short answer: Condensation on a chilled water line is decided by surface temperature, not by the phrase "closed-cell" on a datasheet. Closed-cell material slows vapour diffusion and holds little water, which buys tolerance; it does not lift the surface above dew point or seal a joint. Failures come from thickness, continuity and air leakage, so choose the cell structure for the environment and design the vapour retarder and joints separately.
One word, "sweating", covers two mechanisms solved by different variables. Surface condensation happens when the outer skin falls below the dew point of the surrounding air, governed by air temperature, humidity, the surface heat transfer coefficient and the thermal resistance to the cold medium. ISO 13788:2012 covers surface temperature and interstitial condensation; ISO 12241:2022 gives calculation rules for equipment and installations.
Interstitial condensation is the second failure: vapour moves under a pressure gradient and condenses where the temperature falls below the local dew point, often at the cold wall. Here the controlling quantities are the vapour pressure difference, the diffusion resistance factor of each layer and the temperature profile. A high resistance factor changes this problem substantially but barely affects surface condensation, which depends on thickness and on what the air gives up at the surface. That is how a project swaps mineral wool for closed-cell foam, keeps the thickness, and gets the same dripping surface in the first humid week.
In a closed-cell foam each gas pocket is discrete. For rigid polyisocyanurate the closed-cell content is declared to ASTM D6226, and our PIR datasheet states a minimum of 95%; low conductivity, low water uptake and high vapour resistance follow.
The same datasheet, aged 180 days to ASTM C177, declares 0.024 W/(m·K) at 0 °C, 0.029 W/(m·K) at +50 °C and 0.035 W/(m·K) at +100 °C, water absorption by volume of 2% or less to ASTM D2842, and a vapour transmission coefficient of 5.5 ng/(Pa·s·m) or less to ASTM E96. Our foam rubber range follows the same logic: moisture resistance factor 4,500 < μ < 8,000, conductivity 0.032–0.034 W/(m·K) at 0 °C, service range −50 to +110 °C.
Both ASTM C534/C534M and ASTM C591 require declared absorption and vapour permeability values. But closed-cell structure seals nothing: ASTM C755-20 treats a vapour retarder system as separate, or provided by the insulation only when it has adequate vapour resistance and all joints are sealed.
Mineral fibre is the opposite architecture: a mat of fibres with continuous air paths. Vapour passes comparatively easily, which is why sub-ambient service needs a separate barrier. ASTM C547-22a says so in its scope: on sub-ambient applications, properly installed vapour retarders are needed to reduce moisture movement through or around the insulation, and failure to use one can damage the insulation and system.
Water repellency differs from vapour resistance, and tenders conflate the two. Our glass wool and rock wool datasheets declare hydrophobicity of 98% or more to GB/T 10299, with conductivity of 0.033–0.039 W/(m·K) and 0.043 W/(m·K) at 25 °C. High hydrophobicity means the fibre resists liquid water; it says nothing about vapour diffusion through the mat, or whether the mat can dry once wet.
Open-cell fibrous insulation suits service above dew point, where a jacket and vapour retarder are installed and maintained, where non-combustibility governs and where acoustic absorption matters. It is the wrong choice for a line running continuously below ambient in a humid plant room, because the fibre holds what condenses.
Values are MYREAL datasheet figures; project values come from the declaration of performance.
| Property | Closed-cell (elastomeric, PIR) | Open-cell (glass wool, rock wool) |
|---|---|---|
| Structure | Discrete gas cells; PIR ≥95% closed cell to ASTM D6226 | Continuous air paths between fibres |
| Vapour resistance | High; foam rubber 4,500 < μ < 8,000 | Low; vapour passes through the mat |
| Water absorption | PIR ≤2% by volume to ASTM D2842 | Hydrophobicity ≥98% to GB/T 10299 resists liquid water, not vapour |
| Conductivity, dry | PIR 0.024 W/(m·K) at 0 °C; foam rubber 0.032–0.034 | 0.033–0.043 W/(m·K) at 25 °C |
| Service temperature | PIR −196 to +120 °C; foam rubber −50 to +110 °C | Mineral fibre pipe insulation up to 760 °C (ASTM C547) |
| Surface condensation | Set by thickness and surface conditions | Set by thickness and surface conditions |
| Governing weakness | Joints and terminations; trapped moisture cannot escape | Vapour diffusion and wicking once the jacket is breached |
Take a DN20 copper line, 22 mm outside diameter, water at 7 °C in still air, with h = 8 W/(m²·K) and foam conductivity 0.034 W/(m·K); dew point follows the Magnus relation.
At 26 °C and 60% relative humidity the dew point is 17.6 °C. With 3 mm of insulation the calculated surface temperature is 15.4 °C, which is 2.2 K below dew point: the line runs wet. At 6 mm the surface reaches 19.1 °C, a margin of 1.4 K; at 9 mm, 21.0 °C, a margin of 3.4 K.
Keep the 9 mm and change the room to 30 °C and 70% relative humidity. Dew point rises to 23.9 °C and the surface temperature becomes 24.0 °C, a margin of effectively zero. At 13 mm the surface reaches 25.8 °C and the margin returns to 1.8 K.
The lesson is arithmetic, not branding. Closed-cell foam gave low conductivity and high μ, so these thicknesses are small; the result is still governed by the dew point and the thickness installed. Run the check at the worst humid week.
- Dew point of the actual room at the worst expected humidity, not the annual mean.
- Minimum thickness calculated against that dew point, with a stated margin, at the operating medium temperature.
- Vapour retarder position, continuity and material — or written confirmation that the insulation provides it with every joint sealed (ASTM C755-20).
- Joint, termination and penetration details drawn: flanges, valves, hangers, supports, wall penetrations.
- Declared absorption and vapour transmission values, with the test method named.
- Fire classification from the declaration of performance for the assembled system.
- Jacket and finish: vapour-tight below dew point, mechanically protected where trafficked.
- An inspection point after commissioning in humid weather, with a repair procedure.
Every item is cheaper on a drawing than on a scaffold. Most moisture failures we review are not material failures; they are one of these lines missing, which is why the checklist needs a named owner.
No. ASTM C755-20 treats the vapour retarder system as separate unless the insulation has adequate vapour resistance and every joint is sealed. A closed-cell tube with open butt joints, unsealed ends and bare valves is not a vapour retarder system.
Because those are discontinuities. Valves, strainers, flanges and supports are the coldest exposed surfaces and the hardest to insulate continuously. Fabricated boxes, sealed removable covers and, in severe duty, trace heating are the remedy — not a thicker tube on the straight run.
With a properly installed and maintained vapour retarder and jacket, the condition stated in ASTM C547-22a. Where the surface sits below dew point for long periods and the jacket cannot be inspected, closed-cell is the lower-risk choice: it absorbs little water and does not wick.
Related product ranges: foam rubber · PUR/PIR · glass wool · rock wool
Checking a chilled water or duct insulation specification? Send the pipe sizes, medium temperature and room humidity for a condensation and thickness review →
Prepared by Myreal Energy Saving (Shanghai) Co., Ltd. Technical content for specification support, not a product offer. Confirm thermal values, water absorption and fire classification against the current datasheet and declaration of performance for the selected product.
Contact Person: Mrs. Betsy Ouyang
Tel: +86 177 4080 0950